Children's HealthWatch Opposes Proposed Changes to Public Charge
As pediatricians, public health researchers, and child health and policy experts, we strongly oppose the regulatory proposal “Inadmissibility on Public Charge Grounds” released by the Department of Homeland Security this weekend. This proposal will endanger the health and well-being of families of immigrants and their children.1
Children’s HealthWatch is committed to improving the health and well-being of our nation’s youngest children. We are deeply alarmed by efforts to penalize participation of families with children in evidence-based programs with demonstrated positive health and developmental outcomes. Our scientific research and that of others have repeatedly shown that children thrive when their families have the resources to keep them safe, healthy, well-fed, and stably housed. Ensuring that everyone in our communities has their basic needs met provides the fundamental building blocks of a healthy, prosperous America.
Immigrant families are an integral part of our communities —they are our neighbors, coworkers, friends, and fellow parents. The changes detailed in this rule threaten our country’s health as it forces immigrant families to choose between providing basic necessities that keep children healthy, like food, shelter, and medical care, and having their family remain together in the United States. A policy of fear and punishment, such as the one laid out in this rule, does not build a brighter future for American communities with healthy people and strong workers; to the contrary, such a policy will compromise the health of current and future generations, diminish their ability to excel in school, work and life, and diminish the human potential of communities across the nation.2
Concretely, based on our extensive clinical and research experience, we know this regulatory measure will deter families from accessing programs that could prevent or alleviate economic stressors – even when they are completely eligible for assistance.3 Not receiving needed support will jeopardize the health, and body and brain growth of our youngest children, and the long-term health of our country. Moreover, it will lead to major increases in healthcare costs for the nation.4,5,6 For example, even before the rule was published, families in our pediatric clinics reported making agonizing choices to remove their families from vital assistance programs that ensure their children are able to eat healthy foods and receive medical care, out of fears for their future immigration status. These choices have immediate and lasting consequences for the young patients in our clinics that imperil their current and future health.
Our research over the last twenty years and the work of many others demonstrates that if families are able to access supports when they fall on hard times, the health of all family members, the well-being of our communities, and our economy are strengthened.4,7,8,9
Punishing families utilizing public services designed to improve the health of our entire population places millions of children at risk of adverse health and developmental delays during a critical window of development. This, in turn, will have immediate and long-term effects on our country’s health and education systems, and the strengths and skills of our workforce.
One in four children under age 8 in the U.S. have at least one immigrant parent; of those children, 94 percent were born in the United States.10,11 Even though citizen children with an immigrant parent are more likely to live in a family with a full-time worker compared to children of US-born parents,12 their families disproportionately experience food insecurity, struggle to afford housing costs, and lack access to health care.13,14,15 Each of these hardships is associated with adverse health and developmental outcomes for young children,16,17,18,19 including US citizen children of immigrant mothers.2 The proposed changes to public charge will exacerbate these existing hardships by further preventing families from accessing supports that are currently available to all citizen children and immigrants with certain documented statuses.
As experts in pediatric health and development, we oppose in the strongest terms possible the “Inadmissibility on Public Charge Grounds” proposal and we urge the administration to withdraw it immediately.
This proposal will harm the health of our communities, particularly the current and future health of our youngest children. Physicians take an oath to first do no harm. This rule does unconscionable harm; it will damage the health of tens of thousands of young children, drive up national health care and education costs, and over the long-term, impair national health, educational achievement, and economic status.
1 Perreira K, Hirokazu Y, Oberlander Y. New threat to immigrants’ health – The Public-Charge rule. New England Journal of Medicine. 2018. Available at: https://www.nejm.org/doi/pdf/10.1056/NEJMp1808020
2 Artiga S and Urbri P. Living in an Immigrant Family in America: How Fear and Toxic Stress are Affecting Daily Life, Well-Being, & Health. Kaiser Family Foundation. December 13, 2017. Available at:
3 Padraza F and Zhu L. Immigration Enforcement and the “Chilling Effect” on Latino Medicaid Enrollment. Stanford Center on Poverty and Inequality. January 2015. Available at: https://inequality.stanford.edu/publications/media/details/immigration-e...
4 Cook JT, Poblacion A. Estimating the Health-Related Costs of Food Insecurity and Hunger. In Bread for the World 2016 Hunger Report (www.hungerreport.org).
5 Berkowitz S, Seligman H, Rigdon J. Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) participation and health care expenditures among low-income adults. JAMA, 2017;177(11):1642-1649.
6 Rose-Jacobs R, Black MM, Casey PH, et al. Household food insecurity: Associations with at-risk infant and toddler development. Pediatrics, 2008;121(1):65-72.
7 Poblacion A, Bovell-Ammon A, Sheward R, Sandel M, Ettinger de Cuba S, Cutts D, Cook J. Stable homes make healthy families. Children’s HealthWatch. July 2017. Available at: http://childrenshealthwatch.org/wp-content/uploads/CHW-Stable-Homes-2-pa...
8 Sonik RA. Massachusetts inpatient Medicaid cost response to increased Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program benefits. AJPH, 2016;106(3):443-8.
9 Mathematic Policy Research. The savings in Medicaid costs for newborns and their mothers from prenatal participation in the WIC program. 2017. Available at: https://www.fns.usda.gov/wic/savings-medicaid-costs-newborns-and-their-m...
10 Park M, McHugh M, Katsiaficas. Serving immigrant families through two-generation programs. Migration Policy Institute. 2016. Available at: https://www.migrationpolicy.org/research/serving-immigrant-families-thro...
11 Migration Policy Institute. Children in U.S. immigrant families (By age and state, 1990 versus 2015). Available at: http://www.migrationpolicy.org/programs/data-hub/charts/children-immigra...
12 Kaiser Family Foundation analysis of March 2017 Current Population Survey, Annual Social and Economic Supplement.
13 Capps R. Hardship among Children of Immigrants: Findings from the National Survey of America’s Families. The Urban Institute. 2001; Series B. No.B-29.
14 Hernandez D and Napierala JS. Children in Immigrant Families: Essential to America’s Future. Foundation for Child Development Child and Youth Well-Being Index. 2012.
15 Bovell-Ammon A, Ettinger de Cuba S, Cutts D, Coleman S, Frank DA. Helping our first generation Americans to thrive. Children’s HealthWatch. February 2018. Available at: http://childrenshealthwatch.org/wp-content/uploads/Report-Card-on-Food-I...
16 Sandel M, Sheward R, Ettinger de Cuba S, Coleman S, Frank DA, Chilton M, et al. Unstable housing and caregivern and child health in renter families. Pediatrics. 2018:141(1).
17 Frank DA, Casey PH, Black MM, Rose-Jacobs R, Chilton M, Cutts D, et al. Cumulative hardship and wellness of low-income, young children: Multisite surveillance study. Pediatrics. 2010:125(5).
18 Rose-Jacobs R, Black MM, Casey PH, Cook JT, Cutts DB, Chilton M, et al. Household food insecurity: Associations with at-risk infant and toddler development. Pediatrics. 2008:121;65-72.
19 Ettinger de Cuba s, Sheward R, Poindexter D, Bovell-Ammon A, Ochoa E. Affordable health care keeps children and families healthy. Children’s HealthWatch. Forthcoming.